Published by: Elise Caradec — Editor specializing in consulting
In the face of the dozens of SCPI available on the market, there is a great temptation to rely on the only distribution rate displayed in one of each commercial brochure. However, this is the most common error among new subscribers. Choosing a SCPI involves crossing several financial indicators, to know its own investor profile and to understand the terms of subscription that condition the final taxation. Here is a concrete method of objectively sorting candidates before signing a subscription newsletter.
Define profile and goals before viewing any SCPI
Even before a comparison can be opened, it is necessary to clarify what is really expected of this placement. A typical return SCPI does not meet the same need as a tax SCPI or a foreign-invested SCPI. Consolidating the goals almost always leads to disappointment after a few years.
Supplementary income, tax reduction or wealth diversification
A saver looking for a regular income supplement will turn to Standard performance SCPI, which pays quarterly dividends from rents collected on a diversified asset pool. The first objective of immediate tax optimisation is to look instead at the SCPI tax, which account for less than 10% of total sector capitalisation but meet specific needs, often linked to a high marginal tax bracket. Finally, an investor who already owns a direct real estate asset and simply wishes to dilute its geographical or sectoral risk will be oriented towards diversified or European SCPIs, which pool assets between offices, shops, health or logistics in several countries.
Careful, balanced or dynamic profile
The Risk profile tolerance must also guide the choice. A conservative profile will favour older, widely capitalized SCPIs, with a stable distribution history over a decade. A more dynamic profile will agree to rely on a younger SCPI, still in the process of building its heritage, in exchange for a higher revalue potential, but with a necessarily shorter performance history to analyze.
Financial indicators that really make the difference
Once the objective has been achieved, the figures published by management companies must be read. It is they, and not the commercial discourse, who can objectively judge the quality of a SCPI.
Distribution rate (TD/TDVM) and internal rate of return (TRI)
The distribution rate on market value (TDVM) measures the ratio of dividends paid over a year to the price of the share on January 1. This is the most communicated indicator, but it tells only a part of the story: an increase in the share price without an equivalent increase in the dividend mechanically results in a decrease in the TDVM, even if the SCPI is well on the bottom. The Internal rate of return (IRR), it integrates both the dividends received and the evolution of the value of the share over a given period, usually over a minimum of 10 years for an old SCPI and 5 years for a younger SCPI. It is this indicator that should be given priority in comparing the actual overall performance of two vehicles, rather than stopping at the only posted yield of the current year.
Capitalization: Reassuring size or youth opportunity?
The total capitalization of a SCPI directly conditions its ability to pool rental risks and provide better liquidity in the secondary market for shares. One over EUR 1 billion is generally regarded as a guarantee of safety: the wealth is sufficiently diversified that an isolated rental vacancy does not significantly impact the overall distribution. A young SCPI that already reaches a hundred million euros of capitalization nevertheless deserves to be looked at carefully, provided that it accepts a more limited performance history. A minimum attractive capitalization is generally between EUR 500 million and EUR 600 million to provide a satisfactory first level of mutualisation.
Financial Occupancy Rate (TOF) and Replenishment Value
The rate of financial occupancy measures the share of rents actually received compared to those that would theoretically be received if 100 per cent of the assets were leased. One TOF greater than 90 % is considered a good signal, revealing efficient rental management and a well-positioned heritage. On the other hand, a drop-off TOF often translates into a long-term shortage or rental vacancy, sometimes linked to an aging heritage that requires upgrades. The reconstitution value, on the other hand, corresponds to what would have to be spent to reconstruct the SCPI's heritage, including fees and fees: compared to the price on the part, it allows to identify a possible surcote or haircut.
Debt and fresh: the two lines we read too fast
These are often the least commented criteria in commercial brochures, while they directly affect the net profitability perceived by savers.
What level of debt is acceptable?
One debt between 20% and 30% the value of assets is considered to be sound: it allows the management company to use banking leverage to acquire new assets without weakening the financial structure. Over 40%, the risk becomes significant, as the SCPI's ability to meet its maturities is reduced in the event of lower rents or higher interest rates. Some SCPIs, moreover, exceed 20% of debt without any problem, provided that the rest of the indicators (TOF, capitalisation, seniority of assets) remain solid.
Subscription, management and transaction costs
The Subscription fees, often between 8% and 12% of the share price, are not collected at entry but are smoothed out over the holding period via the difference between the subscription price and the withdrawal price: this is why a investment horizon of at least 8 to 10 years is systematically recommended. The Annual management fees, from the rents received, may exceed 10% depending on the collectives, which directly affects the net distribution rate actually received. In addition, there are charges for the acquisition or disposal of real estate assets, usually between 1% and 2% of the transaction amount, as well as for the monitoring of the work, often between 2% and 4% of the amount committed. These additional charges explain why two SCPIs with a near SDVM can offer a fairly different real net return once all the levies are taken into account.
There is an image that helps to understand why mutualisation is so important in this placement: every building owned by a SCPI works like an isolated risk pocket, able to deteriorate without warning if a major tenant leaves or if a neighbourhood loses its attractiveness. A SCPI that has only a dozen buildings concentrates the shock on a small number of pockets; a SCPI which holds several hundred, divided between offices, shops, health and logistics, dilutes the isolated incident throughout the heritage, without ever cancelling it completely. It is this mechanics of dilution, more than the simple volume of capitalisation, which explains why a broad and heterogeneous wealth cashes rental accidents better than a limited, even of good quality.
How and where to buy shares of SCPI
The chosen channel and envelope directly influence the applicable taxation and the flexibility of the investment management over time.
Accountant, credit or life insurance
The cash subscription remains the most direct route: shares are held live, dividends are taken into account after a period of generally between 3 and 6 months. The credit subscription This may be relevant for an already heavily taxed investor. Accommodation its shares of SCPI within a life insurance contract, in the form of units of account, completely changes the applicable tax system: income is no longer subject to the property income scale but to the taxation of life insurance, generally softer after several years of holding the contract.
Dismemberment to defer taxation
The subdivision of property allows to acquire only the bare ownership of the shares, with a discount on the purchase price between 15% and 45% depending on the duration of the dismemberment chosen. During this period, it is the usufructuary who collects dividends: the bare owner does not receive anything but pays no tax on income which he does not collect, and recovers the full ownership of the shares at maturity, at their market value. This strategy is particularly suitable for an investor who does not need immediate income and who is preparing a medium-term project, such as a supplementary pension.
Diversify rather than rely on a single SCPI
Divide its capital between several SCPIs and several collective societies limit the impact of an isolated counter-performance, whether it is related to a difficult sector, a tense geographical area or an ad hoc management error. A combination of typologies (yield, diversified, European) and capitalization sizes (established SCPI and young developing SCPI) allows for a more resilient exposure than a concentrated investment, even on a SCPI deemed solid on paper.
Taxation, lack of guarantee and deadlines
SCPI's on-line revenues fall under the land income, with a flat-rate reduction of 30 % under the micro-subsidy scheme as long as annual land income remains below EUR 15 000 ; Beyond this, the real regime becomes mandatory, with the possibility of deducting a land deficit up to EUR 10,700 per year, which can be carried forward over 10 years. Financial revenues, in particular those generated by liquidity placed in the framework of the management of the SCPI, are covered by the single flat-rate levy of 30 %of which 12.8% is income tax. It should also be borne in mind that an SCPI does not guarantee the investment capital or the level of dividends paid: past performance never prejudge future performance. The resale of shares is not instantaneous either, with a generally 2-6 month divestiture period depending on the SCPI and the liquidity of the secondary market at the time of application. In case of doubt about an overly insistent offer or trade speech,Financial Markets Authority via its Info Service Savings Service (01 53 45 62 00) remains the right reflex to check the legitimacy of an intermediary before signing anything.
